A Musical View on Education

School teacher... Priest..... Elected official....
What to the three have in common? A belief system.
It is my position that education, religion and politics are similar in that there may not be a "right" answer to everything. I realize that I may be treading into hallowed ground for some people, but all three domains are driven in some way by beliefs.
In education, this can be seen in many different ways. Some topics that bring out emotional discussion in educational circles: phonics/whole language (from the 90's), homework, sex education, cursive handwriting, and even music.
I live on the Seacoast of New Hampshire. Recently a Budget Committee member from a local town expressed his displeasure toward a proposed increase in school music funding. He put an exclamation point on his view by saying that, "I see no evidence to make me not believe that the music program and the band program, as fine as they are, are somewhat of a catch basin for students who cannot qualify to get into more academic programs."
Ouch.
Being a former math teacher I know that statistics can be used to prove various points. I'm sure that folks on both sides of this issue can bring forth statistics in favor of their position. My personal experience regarding music is that it is of critical importance to students of all academic abilities. I never saw music as a "catch basin" for students who struggled in the classroom. I believe that music can only make a more well-rounded student. I have taught many academically talented students who are just as gifted in music.
But from his experience, that Budget Committee member believes in his position.
As in religion and politics, I have certain educational beliefs. Unlike religion where we can just go to our own house of worship and not interact with others, education brings forth issues that have to be debated in public, often leading to heated meetings.
I am just scratching the surface on two issues, music and educational philosphy. I'm sure I will be addressing each in future posts.